KARACHI: Local and foreign businesses expressed divergent views on the State Bank of Pakistan's decision to raise the policy rate by 50 basis points to 12 per cent, The News reported. Local business bodies criticised the move, while the Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce and Industry (OICCI) described it as a right step given the current situation of elevated energy prices amid geopolitical tensions.
The case made by foreign investors
Abdul Aleem Khan, secretary general of the OICCI, said the 50 basis point increase was a cautious approach by the central bank amid the risk of rising inflation as geopolitical tensions have pushed up energy prices, The News reported. "The SBP could have raised the rate by more, but it adopted a cautious approach by increasing it by 50 basis points," he told the newspaper, expressing support for the central bank's decision in the current situation.
The case made by local chambers
Atif Ikram Sheikh, president of the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI), expressed concern and disappointment over the decision to raise the policy rate by another 0.5 percentage points to 12 per cent, which he described as uncompetitive compared with regional economies, The News reported. Sheikh said the FPCCI considered the monetary tightening counterproductive, warning that it can undermine economic stabilisation efforts, dampen industrial expansion and further erode the international competitiveness of Pakistani exports.
At a time when businesses need affordable credit and economic stimulus to boost domestic production, sustain operations and generate employment, further monetary tightening will constrain private-sector growth and weaken investment sentiment, he said, according to the report. In a separate statement reported by industry publications, the FPCCI demanded that monetary policy be recalibrated to bring the rate down to single digits, arguing that Pakistan's inflation is driven by supply-side bottlenecks and energy costs rather than excess demand.
Textile and industrial groups
Other industry groups made similar arguments in statements reported on Monday. The North Karachi Association of Trade and Industry's president, Faisal Moez Khan, warned the increase could raise borrowing costs, weaken exports and slow industrial growth, according to industry reporting. The Pakistan Hosiery Manufacturers Association's north zone office-bearers likewise said the rise would add to textile exporters' costs and urged special financing facilities for export industries. These are the stated positions of the groups concerned, reported here as news. Our explainer on how policy rate changes reach businesses describes the transmission mechanism behind the debate. This article is educational content, not financial advice.
A long-running disagreement
The split is not new. Business groups in Karachi had opposed any hike ahead of the meeting and asked for rates in single digits, according to Dawn's preview of the decision, while one senior banker cited in the same preview said the market needed a larger, 100 basis point increase to tame inflation. The SBP's own account of its reasoning — anchoring expectations against energy and food prices — is set out in our report on the decision itself. Both camps were reacting to the same data: September inflation of 10.3 per cent and oil above $100 a barrel.
Key takeaway: Business reaction to the hike split along familiar lines: the OICCI backed a cautious 50-point step, while the FPCCI and industrial associations called the 12% rate uncompetitive and damaging to exports and growth.