KARACHI: The State Bank's decision to raise the policy rate by 50 basis points to 12% has divided the business community, Dawn reported on Tuesday. Foreign investors supported the increase as a necessary measure against inflation, while local trade and industry associations warned it would raise borrowing costs and strain manufacturing and exports.
The case made by supporters
M. Abdul Aleem of the Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce and Industry welcomed the adjustment as a step to manage inflation and energy price risks, Dawn reported. He pointed to large-scale manufacturing growth of 1.9% in July-August and private sector credit growth of 14.1% year on year as signs the economy could absorb the move.
Supporters of tighter policy generally argue that unanchored inflation damages businesses more over time than a temporary rise in financing costs, because it makes pricing, wages and contracts unpredictable. That was also the reasoning in the Monetary Policy Committee's own statement, covered in our report on the rate hike decision.
The case made by opponents
Leaders of the FPCCI, the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry, the SITE Association of Industry, the Korangi Association of Trade and Industry and the Pakistan Textile Exporters Association opposed the move, according to Dawn's report. KCCI President Talat Mahmood said the increase would further raise the cost of doing business, Business Recorder reported separately.
FPCCI President Atif Ikram Sheikh argued that inflation is being driven by supply constraints, energy costs and fiscal issues rather than excess demand, and urged that the policy rate be brought down to single digits. SITE Association President Abdul Hadi warned manufacturers operating below capacity face higher costs on existing and new borrowing, and textile exporters said working-capital costs would rise for a sector already facing high energy and financing costs. These are the stated positions of the associations, reported here as their views.
Why the split is structural
The disagreement maps onto how different firms experience interest rates. Companies selling to consumers on credit, holding inventories or borrowing for working capital feel a rate rise within weeks. Exporters with foreign-currency earnings and firms with pricing power feel it less directly, while savers and investors in government paper gain from higher returns.
Inflation's causes sit underneath the argument: if price rises come mainly from fuel, food supply and the exchange rate, opponents say rate rises have limited effect on them; if expectations and demand are the channel, supporters say they are essential. The State Bank's statement leaned on expectations, citing the need to contain second-round effects of the supply shock.
What to watch
The practical tests in coming weeks are private sector credit figures, which show whether borrowing slows, and the next inflation prints, which show whether the supply drivers are fading. Both are published on regular schedules by the State Bank and the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics.
This article reports the positions of the named business bodies and the central bank as published by Dawn and Business Recorder, without endorsing any of them. It is educational content, not financial advice.
Key takeaway: Dawn reported a split reaction to the 12% policy rate: the OICCI welcomed it, while the FPCCI, KCCI, SITE, KATI and textile exporters opposed it on cost grounds.