KARACHI: For the next year, Pakistan speaks for the debtors in two rooms at once — a fact of diplomatic positioning that a Dawn analysis ahead of COP31 put at the centre of the climate-finance argument.

The two chairs

Pakistan assumed the chair of the G-24, the Intergovernmental Group of Twenty-Four on International Monetary Affairs and Development, on November 1, succeeding Nigeria, with Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb as chair. At the World Bank-IMF annual meetings in Bangkok last month, Islamabad also took the chair of the Borrowers' Platform, which the Dawn analysis described as giving debtors what creditors have in the Paris Club: a place to pool data, compare terms and bargain as a bloc.

The G-24 coordinates developing-country positions on international monetary and development-finance issues, especially in dealings with the IMF and the World Bank; the chair is a diplomatic role and does not give Pakistan control over either institution's decisions. The Borrowers' Platform chair is the newer and less tested of the two.

Why the timing is the story

The analysis linked the chairs to the structure of climate finance itself: with most public climate finance arriving as loans — the figures in our companion report — debt has become the main channel through which climate money reaches vulnerable countries, and Pakistan, where the analysis put debt servicing at 43% of the federal budget, is itself an example of the constraint. The V20, the bloc of finance ministers from the most climate-vulnerable countries, is separately building a Lifeline Fund that would pool members' reserves into a $500 million emergency facility.

The same analysis carried a criticism alongside the opportunity: Pakistan's absence from the scientific side of the process, including IPCC funding and attendance, sits oddly with its finance diplomacy — a point reported here as the analysis made it, not as this site's view.

The Antalya test

The chairs run for a year; COP31, opening Monday in Antalya and previewed in our main report, is their first test — whether pooled debtor coordination produces anything a single delegation could not.

This report attributes analysis to its source and is educational content, not financial advice.

Key takeaway: Two chairs, one argument: if climate finance is mostly debt, then the debtors' own table — which Pakistan now chairs twice over — is where its terms get contested.