KARACHI: The trilateral talks between Ukraine, Russia and the United States in Abu Dhabi entered their second and final scheduled day on Wednesday, after a first day that ended without an official result — and with the two sides' public descriptions positive in tone and apart on substance.
Day one, as the participants described it
"The trilateral format was constructive and quite substantive. They had time to discuss the need and possible parameters for humanitarian steps," Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said on X after being briefed by his negotiators, adding that the talks covered the substance of security guarantees and the need for de-escalation steps. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who was not present, later told reporters the first day was "very productive".
Ukrainian media reported a possible agreement on a large prisoner exchange in the near future, citing sources in Ukraine's delegation; neither side has officially confirmed a deal, and reports gave no timing or numbers. That distinction — reported by media, unconfirmed by the parties — is how the item stands as day two opens.
The disagreement that remains
The sequencing dispute was spelled out on day one: Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said Russia would not accept an immediate ceasefire without knowing what comes after it, arguing the outlines of a future European security architecture should be agreed first; European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen had said on Monday that any meaningful discussion of Europe's security architecture can only come once a ceasefire in Ukraine is achieved. Territory, including the Donetsk region, remained the toughest item, with nothing said in Abu Dhabi suggesting a breakthrough, AnewZ's account reported.
European representatives held separate consultations in the city but were not part of the formal trilateral talks, the reports said, while the US side — envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner mediating, with Ukraine's delegation led by Rustem Umerov and Russia's by Vladimir Medinsky — signalled separate follow-up meetings with the two presidents may come next.
Why Karachi watches a Gulf negotiating room
The talks are one of the two diplomatic tracks — alongside the US-Iran file — whose progress the oil market is pricing, in our oil report: grain and energy routes through the Black Sea and the Gulf are the concrete channels from these rooms to Pakistan's import bill. No outcome is claimed here beyond what the parties and the reporting state.
This report attributes positions to their holders and flags unconfirmed items as unconfirmed; it is educational content, not financial advice.
Key takeaway: Day one produced adjectives — constructive, productive, substantive — and no document. Wednesday's test is narrower: a confirmed humanitarian step, or another record that the positions are still apart.