KARACHI: September's data releases carried three large debt numbers in two currencies. This explainer sets out what each one counts, why they differ, and how the servicing figures relate to them — using the weekend's published figures as the worked example.

Three totals, three perimeters

Total debt and liabilities — Rs98.88 trillion, in our debt report — is the widest perimeter: the obligations of the government, public sector enterprises, banks, companies and households' institutional lenders, plus liabilities such as foreign exchange liabilities. Central government debt — Rs82.66 trillion, in our central debt report — is narrower: only the federal government's own borrowing, the part serviced from the federal budget. External debt and liabilities — $143.05 billion, in our external report — cuts the same world a different way: everything owed to non-residents, by any Pakistani borrower, in foreign currency terms.

The three overlap without containing each other neatly: the government's external borrowing sits inside both the central government total and the external total, while its domestic borrowing sits only in the first two. Adding any two of the three therefore double-counts.

Stocks are not flows

Each stock figure also has a flow beside it: servicing — the principal repaid and interest paid in a period. The first quarter's flows were $5.63 billion of external servicing and Rs2.90 trillion of total servicing. A stock can rise in the same quarter that servicing is heavy, as happened this quarter, whenever new borrowing exceeds repayments; servicing measures what fell due, the stock measures what remains. Confusing the two is the most common error in debt headlines: a record servicing quarter is a statement about the maturity calendar, not by itself about indebtedness.

A third family of figures — the liquidity schedule, $21.60 billion of expected net outflow in our liquidity report — is neither stock nor past flow but a forward diary of what will fall due.

Which number answers which question

For the federal budget's burden, the central government stock and its mark-up payments — Rs1.70 trillion in the first quarter — are the relevant pair. For foreign-exchange pressure, the external stock, the servicing flow and the liquidity schedule are. For the economy's overall leverage, the widest total, read against GDP of Rs143.60 trillion in the fiscal release, is the starting point. Each question has its own correct figure, and the weekend's releases, read together, provide all of them.

This explainer describes published statistical measures in general terms and is educational content, not financial advice.

Key takeaway: Rs98.88 trillion, Rs82.66 trillion and $143.05 billion are not three estimates of one debt — they are three perimeters, and the right one depends on whether the question is the budget, the balance of payments, or the whole economy.